
A good friend and a strong-in-his-faith Presbyterian believer and I have enjoyed exchanges on the historicity of Jesus and the accuracy of the Bible. He recently gave me a book, The Jesus Discoveries, by Jeremiah Johnston, PhD. The cover of the book states that there are ten historic finds “that bring us face-to-face with Jesus”. I promised to read the book and give my perspectives.
This is the first of what I expect will be a 10-part response.
Discovery 1 – The Shroud of Turin
Before beginning this chapter, I reviewed what I thought I knew/remembered as to the authenticity of the Shroud having been laid over the crucified Jesus. According to Wikipedia:
The documented history of the shroud dates to 1354 when it began to be exhibited in the new collegiate church of Lirey, France. The shroud was denounced as a forgery by the bishop of Troyes in 1389. It was acquired by the House of Savoy in 1453 and later deposited in a chapel in Chambery where it was damaged by fire in 1532. In 1578, the Savoys moved the shroud to their new capital in Turin where it has remained since. In 1694 it was moved to the altar in the Chapel of the Holy Shroud. It remained there until 1993 when it was moved to the cathedral. Ownership of the shroud passed from the House of Savoy to the Catholic Church after the death of king Umberto II of Italy in 1983.
Radiocarbon dating tests [which were] carried out in 1988 concluded with 95% confidence that the material dated to AD 1260–1390 [and] matches the first appearance of the shroud in church history.[
Per Dr. Johnston, “[T]he Shroud brings us face-to-face with the Man of the Shroud – the resurrected Christ himself!” (pg 16) Johnston claims that microscopic analysis shows that the image on the shroud is inconsistent with brush strokes (pg 21). Further, Johnston claims that a study in 1978 proved that the image on the shroud tested positive for serum albumin (blood). (pg22)
Again, according to Wikipedia –
However, Walter McCrone concluded in 1978 by way of a polarized light microscopy examination that a painting technique called pointillism, a methodology wherein small and distinct dots (without brush strokes) are applied in patterns to form an image) and was employed in the 14th century by Simone Martini and other European artists had been used on the Shroud. Furthermore, McCrone reported that no actual blood was present in the samples taken from the Shroud. Rather, the Shroud’s body image had been painted with a dilute pigment of red ochre (a form of iron oxide) in a collagen medium.
Johnston asks, “What is the probability that the man of the Shroud is anyone other than the historical and biblical Jesus? Extremely low based on the converging historical, medical, forensic, and textual data.” (pg 29)
I respect Dr. Johnston’s passion. Yet, given other (and conflicting) scientific results, I’m not convinced that the Shroud of Turin reveals the actual body of Jesus. Johnston puts forth compelling evidence as to what the data and probability may indicate. However, I submit that the variables used for calculating the probability that the Shroud is the actual body of Jesus are those which would have been well known by persons who may “have created” the Shroud. That is, the variables included are such things as the wearing of a crown of thorns, the carrying of a crossbeam, having been nailed to a cross, no leg fractures, etc. These are things which all believers were knowledgeable of since the first century.
Lastly, Johnston himself, in a sense, “tips his hand” as to the believability of the Shroud when he says in his concluding paragraph, “’If’ the Shroud of Turin ‘is indeed’ the burial cloth of Jesus …” (pg 31) Although Dr. Johnston may feel compelled to believe that the Shroud represents the actual image of the crucified Jesus, he uses language that would seem to not venerate his full confidence.
In trying to do a little more research, I stumbled onto a website and found this conclusion:
https://www.shroud.com/78conclu.htm
STURP is the acronym for Shroud of Turin Research Project. They were a team of scientists who studied and evaluated the data and relevant information surrounding the Shroud of Turin. Their conclusions were distributed at a press conference held after STURP’s final meeting in October 1981.
No pigments, paints, dyes or stains have been found on the fibrils. X-ray, fluorescence and microchemistry on the fibrils preclude the possibility of paint being used as a method for creating the image. Ultraviolet and infrared evaluation confirm these studies. Computer image enhancement and analysis by a device known as a VP-8 image analyzer show that the image has unique, three-dimensional information encoded in it. Microchemical evaluation has indicated no evidence of any spices, oils, or any biochemicals known to be produced by the body in life or in death. It’s clear that there has been a direct contact of the Shroud with a body, which explains certain features such as scourge marks, as well as the blood. However, while this type of contact might explain some of the features of the torso, it is totally incapable of explaining the image of the face with the high resolution that has been amply demonstrated by photography.
The basic problem from a scientific point of view is that some explanations which might be tenable from a chemical point of view are precluded by physics. Contrariwise, certain physical explanations which may be attractive are completely precluded by the chemistry. For an adequate explanation for the image of the Shroud, one must have an explanation which is scientifically sound, from a physical, chemical, biological and medical viewpoint. At the present, this type of solution does not appear to be obtainable by the best efforts of the members of the Shroud Team. Furthermore, experiments in physics and chemistry with old linen have failed to reproduce adequately the phenomenon presented by the Shroud of Turin. The scientific consensus is that the image was produced by something which resulted in oxidation, dehydration and conjugation of the polysaccharide structure of the microfibrils of the linen itself. Such changes can be duplicated in the laboratory by certain chemical and physical processes. A similar type of change in linen can be obtained by sulfuric acid or heat. However, there are no chemical or physical methods known which can account for the totality of the image, nor can any combination of physical, chemical, biological or medical circumstances explain the image adequately.
Thus, the answer to the question of how the image was produced or what produced the image remains, now, as it has in the past, a mystery.
We can conclude for now that the Shroud image is that of a real human form of a scourged, crucified man. It is not the product of an artist. The blood stains are composed of hemoglobin [and] give a positive test for serum albumin. The image is an ongoing mystery and until further chemical studies are made, perhaps by this group of scientists, or perhaps by some scientists in the future, the problem remains unsolved.
My own conclusion, then, (at least for now) is that the Shroud of Turin is not the body of Jesus. The evidence presented by Dr. Johnston does not persuade me otherwise. It therefore seems that the Shroud of Turin is not the archaeological discovery that many Christians may wish to purport. To that point, it’s my guess that the Shroud was created by priests and/or others as a celebratory object in the furtherance of Christian worship.
One Response
Bravo… applied science and a reasonable conclusion wins the day! … enough said…